Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 vs Proton Series One Project Black
Both paddles measured on the same 15-trait Paddle DNA test. Proton Series One Project Black takes the higher overall IQ score, but the right pick depends on which traits you value.
Add a third paddle to this comparison →
Paddle DNA head-to-head
- 92Power86
- 80Control86
- 90Spin90
- 78Forgiveness80
- 80Sweet spot82
- 88Stability86
- 68Maneuverability72
- 88Pop82
- 76Touch82
- 80Consistency84
- 82Swing weight76
- 88Twist weight86
- 56Launch angle54
- 90Plow through86
- 62Softness68
Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 vs Proton Series One Project Black specs
Every measured spec side by side. Highlighted values are the better of the two where one is objectively better.
| Spec | Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 | Proton Series One Project Black |
|---|---|---|
| Street price(USD) | $230 | $200 — better |
| IQ score(/ 100) | 82.8 | 83.8 — better |
| Weight(oz) | 8.4 | 8.3 |
| Core thickness(mm) | 16 | 16 |
| Swing weight(kg·cm²)Lower swings faster | 120 | 117 |
| Twist weight(kg·cm²)Higher is more stable | 7.2 — better | 7 |
| Shape | elongated | elongated |
| Face length(in) | 16.5 | 16.5 |
| Face width(in) | 7.5 | 7.5 |
| Handle length(in) | 5.5 | 5.5 |
| Grip circumference(in) | 4.25 | 4.25 |
| Surface | Raw carbon fiber | Raw carbon fiber |
| Core material | Thermoformed unibody with injected foam walls | Thermoformed unibody with foam walls |
Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 verdict
A full foam-wall unibody aimed squarely at the JOOLA and CRBN flagships. Twist weight 88 and plow-through 90 are flagship numbers; the 120 swing weight is the tax you pay for them.
Proton Series One Project Black verdict
A thermoformed unibody built around stability. The foam walls push twist weight to the top of our measured range, which is why off-center drives still land deep.
The verdict
Measured on the same 15-trait test, the clearest separation is power: Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 scores 92 against 86 for Proton Series One Project Black — a 6-point gap. They are effectively level on forgiveness, sweet spot, stability, so those traits should not decide the purchase. Proton Series One Project Black is $30 cheaper at $200.
Power
Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 leads by 6 points (92 vs 86).
Control
Proton Series One Project Black leads by 6 points (86 vs 80).
Pop
Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 leads by 6 points (88 vs 82).
Touch
Proton Series One Project Black leads by 6 points (82 vs 76).
Which one is right for your level?
Each call below re-weights the Paddle DNA traits that matter at that level, so the winner can differ from the overall pick.
Beginner
New to 3.0 — still building a consistent contact point
Too close to call on the traits that matter here (82 vs 83.4 on the weighted index). Take Proton Series One Project Black and keep the $30.
- Consistency
- Forgiveness
- Sweet spot
Intermediate
3.0–3.9 — playing organised rec and early tournaments
Proton Series One Project Black
Proton Series One Project Black is a narrow pick at this level — control 86 vs 80, touch 82 vs 76, maneuverability 72 vs 68. At 117 kg·cm² swing weight it stays quick enough for hands battles.
- Control
- Touch
- Maneuverability
Advanced / tournament
4.0+ — repeatable swing, fast hands battles
Too close to call on the traits that matter here (84.1 vs 84.4 on the weighted index). Take Proton Series One Project Black and keep the $30.
- Touch
- Control
- Maneuverability
Arm-sensitive players
Anyone managing tennis elbow or shoulder load
Proton Series One Project Black
Proton Series One Project Black is a narrow pick at this level — softness 68 vs 62, forgiveness 80 vs 78. Its 16 mm Thermoformed unibody with foam walls core at 8.3 oz is the softer, lower-shock build of the two.
- Softness
- Forgiveness
Which one should you buy?
Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16
Take Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 if you want power (+6), pop (+6), swing weight (+6). Its swing weight of 120 kg·cm² and 16 mm core are what produce that profile.
Read the Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 review →Proton Series One Project Black
Take Proton Series One Project Black if you want control (+6), touch (+6), softness (+6). Its swing weight of 117 kg·cm² and 16 mm core are what produce that profile.
Read the Proton Series One Project Black review →Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 vs Proton Series One Project Black FAQ
- Which is better, the Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 or the Proton Series One Project Black?
- Proton Series One Project Black carries the higher overall Paddle IQ score (83.8 vs 82.8), but IQ is a weighted average. On the trait that separates them most — power — Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 leads by 6 points.
- Which one is faster at the kitchen line?
- Proton Series One Project Black, at 117 kg·cm² swing weight against 120 for Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16. Lower swing weight is the single best predictor of hand speed in fast exchanges.
- Which paddle has more power, the Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 or the Proton Series One Project Black?
- Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 measures 92 on power against 86 for Proton Series One Project Black. That comes from a 16 mm Thermoformed unibody with injected foam walls core swinging at 120 kg·cm² — mass behind the ball, not face material.
- Which one gives more control and touch?
- Proton Series One Project Black at 86 versus 80. Its 16 mm core holds the ball on the face slightly longer, which is what makes resets and dinks land shorter.
- Which paddle spins the ball more?
- Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 scores 90 for spin off its Raw carbon fiber face, against 90 for the Raw carbon fiber face on Proton Series One Project Black. In practice a 0-point gap is small enough that technique matters more.
- Which is more forgiving on off-center hits?
- Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16, with 7.2 twist weight against 7. Higher twist weight means the face rotates less when you miss the middle, and Proton Series One Project Black carries the higher forgiveness score (80) as a result.
- Is the price difference worth it?
- Proton Series One Project Black costs $200, $30 less. Whether that gap is worth closing depends on whether you actually use the traits it trades away — check the head-to-head DNA bars above before paying up.
- Do they use the same core and face?
- Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16: 16 mm Thermoformed unibody with injected foam walls core with a Raw carbon fiber face. Proton Series One Project Black: 16 mm Thermoformed unibody with foam walls core with a Raw carbon fiber face.
- Which is better for a two-handed backhand?
- Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16, at 5.5 in of handle against 5.5 in. Anything under 5.25 in forces you to choke the bottom hand onto the face bevel, which Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 avoids.
- Which one is better for beginners?
- Proton Series One Project Black is the safer first paddle here: forgiveness 80 and sweet spot 82 mean fewer mishits while your contact point is still inconsistent. Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 rewards a repeatable swing and can feel unstable before that.
- Which is lighter in the hand?
- Proton Series One Project Black at 8.3 oz against 8.4 oz. Static weight matters for arm fatigue and elbow comfort; swing weight (117 vs 120) is what you feel mid-rally.
- Is it worth upgrading from the Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 to the Proton Series One Project Black?
- Only if you need what it actually adds. Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 leads on power by 6 points; everything else is within 6 points. At $230 vs $200, the money is better spent elsewhere unless that one trait is your weak spot.
Also worth comparing
Head-to-heads that share DNA with this matchup — useful if you're still deciding between shapes, cores or price tiers.
- Pro XS 16 vs 2X Power Series
- Pro XS 16 vs GX2 Power Elongated
- Pro XS 16 vs CX14E Ultimate Power
- Pro XS 16 vs Hyperion Pro V 16
- Series One Project Black vs Ruby
- Series One Project Black vs Edge 18K V2
- Series One Project Black vs Oni 16
- Series One Project Black vs Pro Ultimate Elongated 16
Top alternatives to both
Paddles that beat one of these two on a specific trait or on price.
Read the full reviews: Legacy Pickleball Pro XS 16 and Proton Series One Project Black. Or build a different comparison, browse the full database or find paddles within 5% of your current one.